城乡公共治理学科的时代价值、内涵特质与建设路径Building an Academic Community for Rural-Urban Public Governance
姜晓萍,张雷
摘要(Abstract):
城乡关系是中国现代化进程中的一对基本矛盾,将城乡公共治理设为公共管理的二级学科,充分体现了公共管理学科应对国家战略转型的主动性与适应性。相较于其他二级学科,城乡公共治理既具有独特的研究范畴与研究范式,又具有利益公共性、交叉融合性与实践应用性的多重特征,正逐步发展为一门独立、成熟的学科。聚焦城市公共治理、农村公共治理及城乡融合发展与治理等问题,学界从治理场域、治理技术与治理体系三大维度展开了丰富的研究,形成了一系列本土化标识性概念。面对学科建设与学术创新的双重发展需求,亟须构建更高水平的城乡公共治理学术共同体,聚焦学科建设的范式创新与体系构建、学术知识的本土提炼与理论应用、学术平台的交流互鉴与包容共生等方面,形成具有中国特色的城乡公共治理学科体系、学术体系、话语体系。
关键词(KeyWords): 城乡公共治理;学术共同体;学科建设;自主知识体系
基金项目(Foundation): 国家社会科学基金重大项目“高质量导向下城乡社区治理和服务体系建设的有效性研究”(项目批准号:21ZDA110),国家社会科学基金重大项目“基于区块链的社区居家养老模式与质量安全体系研究”(项目批准号:21&ZD124)的资助
作者(Author): 姜晓萍,张雷
参考文献(References):
- 曹现强,王新泽.2025.数字形式主义:系统述评、理论框架与未来展望[J].电子政务,(6):64-77.Cao X Q,Wang X Z.2025.Digital formalism:A systematic review,theoretical framework,and future prospects[J].E-Government,(6):64-77.(in Chinese)
- 陈军亚.2023.科层化和社会性:基层治理的结构性问题及破解思路[J].探索与争鸣,(1):32-35.Chen J Y.2023.Bureaucratization and sociality:The structural problems of grassroots governance and solutions[J].Exploration and Free Views,(1):32-35.(in Chinese)
- 陈荣卓,万新波.2024.数字技术赋能基层治理的运行机理及改革进路[J].改革,(12):138-148.Chen R Z,Wan X B.2024.The operational mechanism and reform path of digital technology empowering grassroots governance[J].Reform,(12):138-148.(in Chinese)
- 陈锡文.2010.当前农业和农村经济形势与“三农”面临的挑战[J].中国农村经济,(1):4-9.Chen X W.2010.The current situation of China's agricultural and rural economy and challenges in China's agricultural and rural development[J].Chinese Rural Economy,(1):4-9.(in Chinese)
- 丁波.2022.数字赋能还是数字负担:数字乡村治理的实践逻辑及治理反思[J].电子政务,(8):32-40.Ding B.2022.Digital empowerment or digital burden:The practical logic and governance reflection on digital rural governance[J].E-Government,(8):32-40.(in Chinese)
- 范逢春.2021.新发展阶段城乡基层治理的态势演变、逻辑转换与思路创新[J].行政论坛,28(5):87-95.Fan F C.2021.Rural-urban community-level governance during new development stage:Development,logic shift and thinking innovation[J].Administrative Tribune,28(5):87-95.(in Chinese)
- 范炜烽,白云腾.2023.何以破解“数字悬浮”:基层数字治理的执行异化问题分析[J].电子政务,(10):59-70.Fan W F,Bai Y T.2023.How to crack “digital suspension”:Analysis of the implementation alienation in grassroots digital governance[J].E-Government,(10):59-70.(in Chinese)
- 方长春.2014.中国城市居住空间的变迁及其内在逻辑[J].学术月刊,46(1):100-109.Fang C C.2014.Residential space changing in urban China and its inner logic[J].Academic Monthly,46(1):100-109.(in Chinese)
- 费孝通.2001.中国现代化:对城市社区建设的再思考[J].江苏社会科学,(1):49-52.Fei X T.2001.Reconsidering community construction in the Chinese modern city[J].Jiangsu Social Sciences,(1):49-52.(in Chinese)
- 龚维斌.2021.“十四五”时期推进基层治理现代化研究[J].中国特色社会主义研究,(4):23-29.Gong W B.2021.On promoting modernization of management at the community level in the period of the 14th Five-Year-Plan (2021—2025)[J].Studies on Socialism with Chinese Characteristics,(4):23-29.(in Chinese)
- 韩俊.2009.中国城乡关系演变60年:回顾与展望[J].改革,(11):5-14.Han J.2009.Evolution of the relationship between rural and urban areas in the past sixty years:Looking back and prospect[J].Reform,(11):5-14.(in Chinese)
- 韩瑞波.2021.敏捷治理驱动的乡村数字治理[J].华南农业大学学报(社会科学版),20(4):132-140.Han R B.2021.Analysis of rural digital governance and its practice orientation from the perspective of agile governance[J].Journal of South China Agricultural University (Social Science Edition),20(4):132-140.(in Chinese)
- 韩志明,刘羽晞.2022.“轻便”的智慧治理——来自B镇“一码通用”系统的实践案例[J].理论探讨,(5):54-62.Han Z M,Liu Y X.2022.“Light” smart governance—Practice case of “multifunctional QR code” system in town B[J].Theoretical Investigation,(5):54-62.(in Chinese)
- 贺雪峰.2000a.农民负担与乡村治理——湖北黛村调查[J].管理世界,(6):146-155,181.He X F.2000a.Peasant burden and village governance—An investigation of Dai Village in Hubei[J].Management World,(6):146-155,181.(in Chinese)
- 贺雪峰.2000b.论半熟人社会——理解村委会选举的一个视角[J].政治学研究,(3):61-69.He X F.2000b.On semi-acquaintance society—A perspective for understanding village committee elections[J].CASS Journal of Political Science,(3):61-69.(in Chinese)
- 何雪松,覃可可.2021.城乡社会学视野下的县域社会治理现代化[J].社会科学辑刊,(4):73-79.He X S,Qin K K.2021.The modernization of county social governance from the perspective of urban-rural sociology[J].Social Science Journal,(4):73-79.(in Chinese)
- 何艳玲,周寒.2020.全球体系下的城市治理风险:基于城市性的再反思[J].治理研究,36(4):5-19.He Y L,Zhou H.2020.Urban governance risks under the global system:Rethinking based on urbanity[J].Governance Studies,36(4):5-19.(in Chinese)
- 何艳玲,王铮.2022.统合治理:党建引领社会治理及其对网络治理的再定义[J].管理世界,38(5):115-130.He Y L,Wang Z.2022.Integrated governance:Social governance led by party building and its redefinition of network governance[J].Journal of Management World,38(5):115-130.(in Chinese)
- 何艳玲,蒋良竹.2025.人民性:城市治理的本体论、价值论与方法论——对习近平总书记关于城市工作重要论述的学理阐释[J].北京行政学院学报,(5):105-117.He Y L,Jiang L Z.2025.People-centeredness:Ontology,Value theory,and methodology of urban governance—A theoretical interpretation of Xi Jinping's important discourse on urban work[J].Journal of Beijing Administration Institute,(5):105-117.(in Chinese)
- 侯利文.2019.行政吸纳社会:国家渗透与居委会行政化[J].深圳大学学报(人文社会科学版),36(2):112-121.Hou L W.2019.Administrative absorption of society:State penetration and neighborhood committee administration[J].Journal of Shenzhen University (Humanities & Social Sciences),36(2):112-121.(in Chinese)
- 黄宗智.2008.集权的简约治理——中国以准官员和纠纷解决为主的半正式基层行政[J].开放时代,(2):10-29.Huang Z Z.2008.Centralized minimalism:Semiformal governance by quasi-officials and dispute resolution in China[J].Open Times,(2):10-29.(in Chinese)
- 姜晓萍.2014.国家治理现代化进程中的社会治理体制创新[J].中国行政管理,(2):24-28.Jiang X P.2014.Social governance system innovation in the process of national governance modernization[J].Chinese Public Administration,(2):24-28.(in Chinese)
- 姜晓萍,田昭.2019.授权赋能:党建引领城市社区治理的新样本[J].中共中央党校(国家行政学院)学报,23(5):64-71.Jiang X P,Tian Z.2019.Empowerment:A new model of urban community governance led by the party buidling[J].Journal of the Party School of the Central Committee of the C.P.C.(Chinese Academy of Governance),23(5):64-71.(in Chinese)
- 姜晓萍,杨舒雯.2024.合法性动机与选择性策略:农村基层减负悖论的生成逻辑[J].行政论坛,31(4):145-154.Jiang X P,Yang S W.2024.Legitimacy motivation and selective strategy:The generative logic of the paradox of burden reduction in rural grassroots[J].Administrative Tribune,31(4):145-154.(in Chinese)
- 姜晓萍,曹现强,何艳玲,等.2025.推进现代化人民城市建设(笔谈)[J].行政论坛,32(5):5-29.Jiang X P,Cao X Q,He Y L,et al.2025.Promoting the construction of modern cities of the people (written discussion)[J].Administrative Tribune,32(5):5-29.(in Chinese)
- 景跃进.2019.将政党带进来——国家与社会关系范畴的反思与重构[J].探索与争鸣,(8):85-100,198.Jing Y J.2019.Bringing the party in—Reflection and reconstruction of the dichotomy of state-society relationship[J].Exploration and Free Views,(8):85-100,198.(in Chinese)
- 康晓光,韩恒.2007.行政吸纳社会——当前中国大陆国家与社会关系再研究[J].中国社会科学(英文版),28(2):116-128.Kang X G,Han H.2007.Administrative absorption of society:A further probe into the state-society relationship in Chinese Mainland[J].Social Sciences in China,28(2):116-128.(in Chinese)
- 李强,王美琴.2009.住房体制改革与基于财产的社会分层秩序之建立[J].学术界,(4):25-33.Li Q,Wang M Q.2009.The reform of housing system and the establishment of property-based social stratification order[J].Academics in China,(4):25-33.(in Chinese)
- 林聚任.2022.新城乡空间重构与城乡融合发展[J].山东大学学报(哲学社会科学版),(1):72-81.Lin J R.2022.New urban-rural spatial restructuring and urban-rural integrated development in China[J].Journal of Shandong University (Philosophy and Social Sciences),(1):72-81.(in Chinese)
- 刘超.2022.城镇化进程中的农民家庭策略与发展型家庭秩序——基于“一家三制”的讨论[J].宁夏社会科学,(1):161-167.Liu C.2022.Peasant family strategies and developmental family order in the process of urbanization—A discussion based on the “One Family,Three Systems” model[J].Ningxia Social Sciences,(1):161-167.(in Chinese)
- 刘建军.2016.社区中国:通过社区巩固国家治理之基[J].上海大学学报(社会科学版),33(6):73-85.Liu J J.2016.Communal China:Enhancing the foundation of state governance through communities[J].Journal of Shanghai University (Social Sciences Edition),33(6):73-85.(in Chinese)
- 刘伟,黄佳琦.2020.乡村治理现代化中的简约传统及其价值[J].厦门大学学报(哲学社会科学版),(3):40-48.Liu W,Huang J Q.2020.Minimalism tradition and its value in the modernization of rural governance[J].Journal of Xiamen University (Arts & Social Sciences),(3):40-48.(in Chinese)
- 刘晔.2001.治理结构现代化:中国乡村发展的政治要求[J].复旦学报(社会科学版),(6):56-61,79.Liu Y.2001.Modernization of governing structure:Political requirements for rural development in China[J].Fudan Journal (Social Sciences Edition),(6):56-61,79.(in Chinese)
- 陆益龙.2015.后乡土中国的基本问题及其出路[J].社会科学研究,(1):116-123.Lu Y L.2015.The basic problems and outlet of post-rural China[J].Social Science Research,(1):116-123.(in Chinese)
- 马梦岑,李威利.2020.房权社会与圈层结构:中国城市空间权利的兴起及其治理[J].甘肃行政学院学报,(6):102-110,128.Ma M C,Li W L.2020.Housing rights society and concentric circle structure:The rise and governance of urban space rights in China[J].Journal of Gansu Administration Institute,(6):102-110,128.(in Chinese)
- 孟燕,方雷.2023.价值驱动、结构优化与主体赋能:基层治理共同体的建构逻辑[J].江苏社会科学,(2):116-125.Meng Y,Fang L.2023.Value-driven,structure-optimized,and actor-empowered:The logical framework for building grassroots governance communities[J].Jiangsu Social Sciences,(2):116-125.(in Chinese)
- 欧阳静.2022.简约治理:超越科层化的乡村治理现代化[J].中国社会科学,(3):145-163,207.Ouyang J.2022.Minimal governance:Rural governance modernization that transcends bureaucracy[J].Social Sciences in China,(3):145-163,207.(in Chinese)
- 潘泽泉,辛星.2021.政党整合社会:党建引领基层社区治理的中国实践[J].中南大学学报(社会科学版),27(2):153-163.Pan Z Q,Xin X.2021.Social integration by political party:Chinese practice that party building guides community governance[J].Journal of Central South University (Social Sciences),27(2):153-163.(in Chinese)
- 彭勃,杜力.2022.“超行政治理”:党建引领的基层治理逻辑与工作路径[J].理论与改革,(1):59-75,156-157.Peng B,Du L.2022.“Super-administrative governance”:The governance logic and working path of primary-level governance led by party building[J].Theory and Reform,(1):59-75,156-157.(in Chinese)
- 孙明扬.2020.中国农村的“老人农业”及其社会功能[J].南京农业大学学报(社会科学版),20(3):79-89.Sun M Y.2020.The old-age agriculture in China's rural areas and its social function[J].Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Sciences Edition),20(3):79-89.(in Chinese)
- 唐文玉.2010.行政吸纳服务——中国大陆国家与社会关系的一种新诠释[J].公共管理学报,7(1):13-19.Tang W Y.2010.Administrative absorption of service—A new interpretation of the state-society relationship in Chinese Mainland[J].Journal of Public Management,7(1):13-19.(in Chinese)
- 唐亚林,郝文强.2023.人民城市的理论逻辑、历史逻辑与实践逻辑[J].行政论坛,30(6):13-22.Tang Y L,Hao W Q.2023.The theoretical logic,historical logic,and practical logic of the people's city[J].Administrative Tribune,30(6):13-22.(in Chinese)
- 王春光.2020.县域社会学研究的学科价值和现实意义[J].中国社会科学评价,(1):36-46,157-158.Wang C G.2020.The disciplinary value and practical significance of county sociological research[J].China Social Science Review,(1):36-46,157-158.(in Chinese)
- 王佃利,徐静冉.2024.服务与空间融合:基层治理共同体建设的优化路径[J].华南师范大学学报(社会科学版),(2):6-18,205.Wang D L,Xu J R.2024.Service and space integration:Analysis of the optimized path of grassroots governance community[J].Journal of South China Normal University (Social Science Edition),(2):6-18,205.(in Chinese)
- 王敬尧,黄祥祥.2022.县域治理:中国之治的“接点”存在[J].行政论坛,29(4):81-90.Wang J Y,Huang X X.2022.County governance:The junction of China's governance[J].Administrative Tribune,29(4):81-90.(in Chinese)
- 王敬尧,郑鹏.2025a.家国互动中基层治理单元的形变与适配[J].厦门大学学报(哲学社会科学版),75(2):181-190.Wang J Y,Zheng P.2025a.Deformation and adaptation of grassroots governance units in the interaction of family and state[J].Journal of Xiamen University (Arts & Social Sciences),75(2):181-190.(in Chinese)
- 王敬尧,郑鹏.2025b.中国式城乡融合发展中的空间权利建构[J].社会科学研究,(4):47-54,227.Wang J Y,Zheng P.2025b.The construction of spatial rights in the integrated urban-rural development with Chinese characteristics[J].Social Science Research,(4):47-54,227.(in Chinese)
- 王颖.2000.城市发展研究的回顾与前瞻[J].社会学研究,(1):65-75.Wang Y.2000.Review and prospect of urban development research[J].Sociological Research,(1):65-75.(in Chinese)
- 文宏,林仁镇.2022a.多元如何共治:新时代基层社会治理共同体构建的现实图景——基于东莞市横沥镇的考察[J].理论探讨,(1):62-69.Wen H,Lin R Z.2022a.How can multiple parties co-govern?The realistic picture of building a grassroots social governance community in the new era—Based on the investigation of Hengli Town,Dongguan[J].Theoretical Investigation,(1):62-69.(in Chinese)
- 文宏,林仁镇.2022b.城市基层治理共同体建构中的情感生成逻辑——基于佛山市南海区的实践考察[J].探索,(5):141-151.Wen H,Lin R Z.2022b.The logic of emotion generation in the construction of urban primary-level governance community—A practical study in Nanhai District,Foshan City[J].Probe,(5):141-151.(in Chinese)
- 吴建南,王亚星.2023.中国式城市治理现代化的历史演进、变迁特征与未来走向[J].政治学研究,(6):14-26.Wu J N,Wang Y X.2023.Historical evolution,changing characteristics and future direction of Chinese path to urban governance modernization[J].CASS Journal of Political Science,(6):14-26.(in Chinese)
- 吴理财,杨桓.2012.城镇化时代城乡基层治理体系重建——温州模式及其意义[J].华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版),51(6):10-16.Wu L C,Yang H.2012.Rebuilding the urban and rural grassroots governance system in the era of urbanization:The Wenzhou model and its significance[J].Journal of Huazhong Normal University (Humanities and Social Sciences),51(6):10-16.(in Chinese)
- 吴晓林.2020.城市性与市域社会治理现代化[J].天津社会科学,(3):75-82.Wu X L.2020.Urbanity and the modernization of municipal social governance[J].Tianjin Social Sciences,(3):75-82.(in Chinese)
- 吴晓林.2024.城市基层治理的产权逻辑——基于“产权类型—分配过程”的分析[J].政治学研究,(3):155-167.Wu X L.2024.The property rights logic of urban grassroots governance in China:Analysis based on “property rights types-distribution process”[J].CASS Journal of Political Science,(3):155-167.(in Chinese)
- 吴晓林,谢伊云.2020.国家主导下的社会创制:城市基层治理转型的“凭借机制”——以成都市武侯区社区治理改革为例[J].中国行政管理,(5):91-98.Wu X L,Xie Y Y.2020.The state initiates and regulates society:“Bridging Mechanism” for the transformation of urban grassroots governance in China—A case study of community governance reform in Wuhou District,Chengdu[J].Chinese Public Administration,(5):91-98.(in Chinese)
- 吴晓林,李一.2022.空间黏合:城市生活空间改造中基层治理共同体的形成机理[J].广西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),58(4):28-39.Wu X L,Li Y.2022.Spatial cohesion:The formation mechanism of primary-level governance community in the transformation of urban living space[J].Journal of Guangxi Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition),58(4):28-39.(in Chinese)
- 夏志强,陈佩娇.2021.城市治理中的空间正义:理论探索与议题更新[J].四川大学学报(哲学社会科学版),(6):189-198.Xia Z Q,Chen P J.2021.Spatial justice in urban governance:Theoretical exploration and update of research subjects[J].Journal of Sichuan University (Philosophy and Social Science Edition),(6):189-198.(in Chinese)
- 夏柱智,贺雪峰.2017.半工半耕与中国渐进城镇化模式[J].中国社会科学,(12):117-137.Xia Z Z,He X F.2017.China's semi-industrial,semi-agricultural mode and incremental urbanization[J].Social Sciences in China,(12):117-137.(in Chinese)
- 项继权,李增元.2012.经社分开、城乡一体与社区融合——温州的社区重建与社会管理创新[J].华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版),51(6):1-9.Xiang J Q,Li Z Y.2012.Separation of rconomy and society,urban-rural integration,and community integration:Community reconstruction and social management innovation in Wenzhou[J].Journal of Huazhong Normal University (Humanities and Social Sciences),51(6):1-9.(in Chinese)
- 肖滨.2020.构筑共和国的微观基础——对桐乡“三治融合”实践经验尝试性的一种理论解读[J].治理研究,36(6):11-12.Xiao B.2020.Building the microfoundations of the republic:A tentative theoretical interpretation of Tongxiang's “Integration of Governance Approaches” practice[J].Governance Studies,36(6):11-12.(in Chinese)
- 肖滨.2023.基层政治参与单元有效运行的中国方案——浙江省打造“基层单元”实践经验的理论解读[J].政治学研究,(3):60-68.Xiao B.2023.Chinese approaches to strengthening grassroots political participation units:A theoretical analysis of the practical implementation of ‘Grassroots Units’ in Zhejiang,China[J].CASS Journal of Political Science,(3):60-68.(in Chinese)
- 徐勇.2002.县政、乡派、村治:乡村治理的结构性转换[J].江苏社会科学,(2):27-30.Xu Y.2002.County administration,township dispatch,and village governance:The structural transformation of rural governance[J].Jiangsu Social Sciences,(2):27-30.(in Chinese)
- 徐勇.2003.乡村治理与中国政治[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社:235.Xu Y.2003.Rural governance and Chinese politics[M].Beijing:China Social Sciences Press:235.(in Chinese)
- 徐勇.2022.将概念带入学术体系:为“概念孤儿”寻家[J].中国社会科学评价,(4):4-10.Xu Y.2022.Bringing concepts into academic system:Finding a home for “Conceptual Orphans”[J].China Social Science Review,(4):4-10.(in Chinese)
- 徐勇,吴毅,贺雪峰,等.2002.村治研究的共识与策略[J].浙江学刊,(1):26-32.Xu Y,Wu Y,He X F,et al.2002.Consensus and strategies in village governance research[J].Zhejiang Academic Journal,(1):26-32.(in Chinese)
- 杨华.2025.中国县域治理的结构转换及其逻辑研究[J].社会科学,(6):115-128.Yang H.2025.Structural transformation and the underlying logic of county governance in China[J].Journal of Social Sciences,(6):115-128.(in Chinese)
- 杨宏山.2012.城乡关系与地方治理改革[J].北京行政学院学报,(5):26-30.Yang H S.2012.Urban-rural relationship and local governance reform[J].Journal of Beijing Administrative College,(5):26-30.(in Chinese)
- 杨开峰,仇纳青,郭一帆.2024.“三治融合”:重塑当代中国基层社会与基层治理[J].公共管理与政策评论,13(1):3-18.Yang K F,Qiu N Q,Guo Y F.2024.“Integrated governance of the three realms”:Restructuring contemporary grassroots society and grassroots governance in China[J].Public Administration and Policy Review,13(1):3-18.(in Chinese)
- 杨嵘均.2021.城乡基层智慧治理体系构建的基本范式、制约因素与创新路径[J].河海大学学报(哲学社会科学版),23(4):60-67,107.Yang R J.2021.On the basic paradigm,constraints and innovation path of urban and rural smart governance system construction[J].Journal of Hohai University (Philosophy and Social Sciences),23(4):60-67,107.(in Chinese)
- 国务院发展研究中心农业农村部课题组.2014.从城乡二元到城乡一体——我国城乡二元体制的突出矛盾与未来走向[J].管理世界,(9):1-12.
- 伊曼纽尔·沃勒斯坦.2006.知识的不确定性[M].王昺,等,译.济南:山东大学出版社:104.Wallerstein I.2006.The uncertainties of knowledge[M].Wang B,et al.,trans.Jinan:Shandong University Press:104.(trans.into Chinese)
- 尹栾玉,隋音.2023.基层治理共同体的理论意蕴与现实运行逻辑——基于马克思“真正的共同体”理论视角[J].社会政策研究,(1):37-50.Yin L Y,Sui Y.2023.The theoretical implication and realistic logic of the community of grassroots governance:From the perspective of Marx' theory of “True Community”[J].Social Policy Research,(1):37-50.(in Chinese)
- 郁建兴.2018-11-13(005).深化“三治融合”提升基层治理水平[N].浙江日报.Yu J X.2018-11-13(005).Deepening the integration of governance by the people,the government,and the rule of law to enhance grassroots governance[N].Zhejiang Daily.(in Chinese)
- 郁建兴,任泽涛.2012.当代中国社会建设中的协同治理——一个分析框架[J].学术月刊,44(8):23-31.Yu J X,Ren Z T.2012.Collaborative governance in contemporary Chinese social development:An analysis framework[J].Academic Monthly,44(8):23-31.(in Chinese)
- 郁建兴,任杰.2020.社会治理共同体及其实现机制[J].政治学研究,(1):45-56,125-126.Yu J X,Ren J.2020.Social governance community and its implementation institutions design[J].CASS Journal of Political Science,(1):45-56,125-126.(in Chinese)
- 袁方成,周韦龙.2022.从振兴共同体到共同体振兴:乡村振兴的乡贤逻辑[J].社会主义研究,(2):101-109.Yuan F C,Zhou W L.2022.From revitalizing the community to revitalization of the community:The logic of the able villagers in rural revitalization[J].Socialism Studies,(2):101-109.(in Chinese)
- 张雷,杜泽.2024.基于区块链的“去中心化”物业管理互信共治新模式[J].东北大学学报(社会科学版),26(1):73-81.Zhang L,Du Z.2024.A new model of mutual trust and co-governance of “Decentralized” property management based on blockchain[J].Journal of Northeastern University (Social Sciences),26(1):73-81.(in Chinese)
- 张龙辉,赵泽泉.2022.技术治理范式下城市风险治理的变革、隐忧及效能提升路径[J].求实,(3):43-58,110.Zhang L H,Zhao Z Q.2022.The transformation,hidden worries and efficiency improvement of urban risk management under the technology governance paradigm[J].Truth Seeking,(3):43-58,110.(in Chinese)
- 张琦,杨铭宇.2021.空间治理:乡村振兴发展的实践路向——基于Q市“美丽乡村建设”的案例分析[J].南京农业大学学报(社会科学版),21(6):128-139.Zhang Q,Yang M Y.2021.Analysis on the path of rural spatial governance from the perspective of rural revitalization:Based on the case analysis of “Beautiful Countryside Construction” in Q city[J].Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Sciences Edition),21(6):128-139.(in Chinese)
- 张文显.2020.“三治融合”之理[J].治理研究,36(6):5-8.Zhang W X.2020.The principle of “Integration of Autonomy,Rule of Law,and Rule of Virtue”[J].Governance Studies,36(6):5-8.(in Chinese)
- 张现洪.2019.技术治理与治理技术的悖论与迷思[J].浙江学刊,(1):160-165.Zhang X H.2019.Paradox and confusion on technical governance and governing technology[J].Zhejiang Academic Journal,(1):160-165.(in Chinese)
- 赵吉,彭勃.2021.社会借道行政:后脱钩时代行业协会自我增能的有效机制[J].治理研究,37(1):37-46.Zhao J,Peng B.2021.Society borrowing the path of administration:An effective mechanism for self-empowerment of industry associations in the post-decoupling era[J].Governance Studies,37(1):37-46.(in Chinese)
- 赵晓峰.2014.中国农村基层的简约主义治理:发生机制与功能定位[J].西北农林科技大学学报(社会科学版),14(6):127-131.Zhao X F.2014.Contracted management in rural China:Mechanism and function[J].Journal of Northwest A&F University (Social Science Edition),14(6):127-131.(in Chinese)
- 赵秀玲.2020.中国古代乡村治理资源的价值重估[J].东南学术,(3):115-121.Zhao X L.2020.Re-evaluating the value of ancient Chinese rural governance resources[J].Southeast Academic,(3):115-121.(in Chinese)
- 周俊,郁建兴.2024.当代中国基层社会如何可能——基于浙江桐乡“三治融合”建设的案例分析[J].政治学研究,(1):167-180.Zhou J,Yu J X.2024.How is it possible for contemporary grassroots society in China—Case analysis of “Three Governance Integration” construction in Tongxiang,Zhejiang Province[J].CASS Journal of Political Science,(1):167-180.(in Chinese)
- 周立,程梦瑶,郑霖